NAT’S NEW YORK PIZZA MENU

🍕 Nat’s New York Pizzeria on West Broadway in Vancouver is a Kitsilano favourite serving authentic thin-crust New York–style pizza, hearty hero sandwiches, pasta, and fresh salads. Known for classics like Margherita, Meat Lovers, and Pesto Artichoke, Nat’s delivers a true East Coast slice in a casual, family-run setting. A landmark pizzeria in the neighbourhood, it’s a go-to for locals and visitors craving real New York flavour in the heart of Vancouver.

Nat’s New York Pizzeria menu in Vancouver:

🍕 Vegetarian Pizzas

• Margherita (Cheese)

  Classic marinara sauce topped with Nat’s special low-moisture cheese blend.

• Mushroom

  Thinly sliced mushrooms cooked until perfectly tender.

• Spicy Mushroom

  Thick-cut mushrooms with a bold, spicy kick.

• Pesto Artichoke

  Made with Nat’s house-made pesto and artichoke hearts for a rich, earthy flavour.

• Hot ’n Sweet

  A lively mix of mushrooms, hot bell peppers, and pineapple.

• 5th Avenue

  Spinach, fresh tomatoes, sweet onions, and creamy feta cheese.

• Hot Veg

  Sundried tomatoes, zucchini, mushrooms, and hot bell peppers.

• Tomato & Onion Salad

  Tomatoes, onions, capers, bocconcini, and fresh garlic.

• Kits Italiano!

  Broccoli, zucchini, cherry tomatoes, and black olives.

• The Basic Veg

  Mushrooms, green peppers, black olives, and tomatoes.

• The Vegan (No Cheese)

  A dairy-free mix of mushrooms, sweet onions, artichoke, black olives, and fresh garlic.

🍖 Meat Lovers

• Pepperoni

  Nat’s most loved pie, loaded with classic pepperoni.

• The Waikiki

  A tropical favourite with ham and pineapple.

• Chorizo Mushroom

  A house favourite with spicy chorizo sausage and mushrooms.

• Domino’s

  A timeless combo of pepperoni, mushrooms, and green peppers.

• Meat Deluxe

  A hearty pie with pepperoni, chorizo, mushrooms, onions, and red & green peppers.

• Beef Eater

  Ground beef paired with feta, tomatoes, and onions.

• Italian Classic

  Italian sausage, red peppers, Sicilian olives, white onions, and garlic.

• Meathead

  Salami, ham, and seasoned ground beef for the ultimate meat feast.

• Uncle Tony

  Salami, white onions, anchovies, and fresh garlic.

• Uncle Al

  Hot capicola, hot bell peppers, sweet onions, and roasted garlic.

• Uncle Joe

  Anchovies, fresh tomatoes, sweet onions, and garlic.

⭐ Specialty Pizzas

• Pizza Bianca

  Olive oil base topped with broccoli, four cheeses, red peppers, and Kalamata olives.

• NY Deli

  A deli-inspired pie with capicola, pepperoni, salami, and ham.

• BBQ Chicken

  BBQ chicken, ranch, olive oil, sweet onion, bell pepper, and Nat’s own BBQ sauce.

• Maui Wowie

  BBQ chicken with ham, peppers, onions, and pineapple.

• El Taco

  A taco-style pizza with seasoned beef, shredded lettuce, diced tomatoes, olives, mozzarella, cheddar, and chives.

• Four Cheese

  A rich blend of mozzarella, feta, parmesan, and ricotta.

• The Hilton

  A fiery favourite with capocollo, hot bell peppers, and spicy mushrooms.

🍕 Build Your Own Pizza

Get creative with your pizza!

• Regular Toppings

  Pepperoni, ham, mushrooms, tomatoes, onions, peppers, spinach, pineapple, olives, garlic, and more.

• Double Cheese

  Extra layers of mozzarella for serious cheese lovers.

🍷 Gourmet Toppings

• Gourmet Choices

  Chorizo, Italian sausage, seasoned chicken or beef, bacon, capicola, salami, anchovies, spicy mushrooms, broccoli, artichokes, sundried tomatoes, zucchini, pesto, Feta, bocconcini.

🥗 Salads

• Caesar Salad

  Crisp romaine tossed with house-made Caesar dressing and crunchy croutons.

• Chicken Caesar

  Classic Caesar salad topped with tender grilled chicken.

• House Salad

  Fresh greens with crisp vegetables, served with oil and vinegar dressing.

• Greek Salad

  A Mediterranean favorite with cucumbers, tomatoes, olives, red onion, and feta cheese.

🍲 Soup

• Mamma Rosa’s Chicken Vegetable Soup

  A comforting bowl of chicken, hearty vegetables, and savory broth, made from a family recipe.

🍝 Spaghetti

• Spaghetti in Marinara Sauce

  Traditional marinara sauce served over al dente spaghetti.

• Spaghetti in Olive Oil and Garlic

  Light and fragrant with olive oil, garlic, and herbs.

• Spaghetti & Meatballs

  Classic spaghetti topped with hearty house-made meatballs.

• Spaghetti Primavera

  A vegetarian delight with mushrooms, broccoli, and peppers.

• Spaghetti Bolognese

  Rich, slow-simmered meat sauce over spaghetti.

• Spaghetti & Sausage

  Savory Italian sausage served with spaghetti and sauce.

🍝 Penne

• Penne Broccoli

  Tender penne with broccoli, tossed in olive oil or garlic sauce.

• Penne + Italian Sausage

  Penne pasta with savory Italian sausage and house tomato sauce.

• Penne Primavera

  A fresh mix of vegetables with penne pasta.

• Penne + Olive Oil + Garlic

  Light and simple—penne tossed with garlic and olive oil.

• Baked Penne

  Oven-baked pasta with tomato sauce and melted cheese.

• Baked Penne + Meat Sauce

  A heartier version baked with meat sauce and cheese.

• Penne Marinara

  Penne pasta with Nat’s signature marinara sauce.

• Penne Bolognese

  Penne pasta topped with rich, meaty Bolognese sauce.

🧀 Lasagna

• Traditional Lasagna

  Layers of pasta, cheese, and rich tomato sauce baked to golden perfection.

🥪 Heros (The OG Sub)

• Chicken Cutlet Parmesan

  Crispy chicken cutlet topped with marinara and melted cheese.

• Veal Cutlet Parmesan

  Breaded veal cutlet smothered in sauce and melted cheese.

• Cold Chicken Deluxe

  Stacked with cold chicken, lettuce, tomato, and house dressing.

• Italian Deli Deluxe

  A hearty deli-style sub layered with Italian cold cuts and toppings.

• Eggplant Parmesan

  Breaded eggplant with marinara and melted cheese.

• Cold Eggplant Deluxe

  A lighter take on the Italian sub with eggplant and crisp vegetables.

• Sausage Deluxe Parmesan

  Italian sausage baked with marinara and melted cheese.

🥖 Bread

• Garlic Bread

  House-made with rich garlic butter, baked until golden.

• Footlong Cheese Bread with Pepperoni

  A hearty loaf topped with melted cheese and layers of pepperoni.

• Footlong Cheese Bread

  Cheesy, oven-baked bread that’s perfect for sharing.

🍖 Meatballs

• Side of Meatballs

  Classic Italian meatballs simmered in marinara.

🥫 Dips

• Ranch or Marinara

  Your choice of creamy ranch or tangy marinara for dipping.

🧀 Parmesan

• Side of Parm

  A sprinkle of freshly grated Parmesan to elevate any dish.

🕒 Anytime Specials

• NY 001 – Big Cheese Slice with Pepsi

  A giant New York slice with a 16oz Pepsi.

• NY 002 – Any Two Slices with Soda

  Your choice of two pizza slices with a 24oz soda.

🥗 Lunch Specials

Popular combos that get you in and out quickly.

• NY No. 1 – Pizza Lunch

  Any slice, a fresh green salad, and a 16oz soda.

• NY No. 2 – Soup + Slice

  Any slice paired with Mamma Rosa’s chicken vegetable soup.

• NY No. 3 – Pasta Lunch

  Daily pasta, green salad, and a 16oz soda.

• NY No. 4 – Soup + Salad

  Green salad with Mamma Rosa’s chicken vegetable soup.

• NY No. 5 – Half Chicken Hero

  A half chicken hero with a small green salad and 16oz soda.

📖 See the current Nat’s New York Pizzeria menu on their website

⭐ Customer Favorite Menu Items

• Pesto Artichoke Pizza – A top pick with Nat’s signature pesto base and tender artichokes.

• Margherita / Cheese Pizza – Classic thin-crust with house marinara and mozzarella.

• Chicken Deluxe Hero – A hearty, flavour-packed sub that regulars rave about.

• Upside-Down / Melenzane Pizzas – Sauce-forward, Italian-inspired options that stand out.

• Meat Lovers & Pepperoni Pizzas – Generous portions and loaded with flavour.

• Salads & Pastas – Fresh sides that pair perfectly with their New York pies.

🍽 Dining Experience

• Family-owned and community-driven with New York pizzeria vibes.

• Walls decorated with vintage pizza memorabilia and neighbourhood character.

• Quick and casual service — pizzas typically take 20–25 minutes to bake fresh.

• Recipes rooted in Italian heritage and New York tradition, passed down through the owners’ family.

🚗 Parking & Accessibility

• Street parking available along Broadway and nearby side streets.

• Additional public lots within walking distance.

• Easy transit access with several bus routes running along Broadway.

• Ground-level entry makes it convenient for walk-ins and pick-ups.

📍 Landmarks & Location

• Situated on Broadway in Vancouver’s lively Kitsilano neighbourhood.

• Close to local shops, cafés, and community hangouts.

• Longtime fixture with a reputation as one of the area’s original New York-style pizza spots.

🛍️ Ordering Options

• Dine-in for a casual neighbourhood pizza experience.

• Takeout available for quick slices or whole pies.

• Hero sandwiches, salads, and pasta offered alongside pizzas.

• Loyal local following, with many repeat customers.

💬 Customer Feedback

• Praised as “the best New York pie in the city” by many locals.

• Staff and owners are often described as welcoming and friendly.

• Crust consistently noted as thin, crisp, and flavourful.

• Some reviews note longer prep times during busy hours, but worth the wait.

• Strong community feel keeps regulars coming back year after year.

This menu was last updated: 3 weeks ago.